Alfred Smudits:

Mediamorphosen des Kulturschaffens

Kunst und Kommunikationstechnologien im Wandel
Publication Series "Musik und Gesellschaft", Volume 27
Published by Braumüller-Verlag, Vienna 2002
Since the early 1990s, there has been a veritable boom in publications on the history of communication and media, as well as on media theory. This growing interest in media theory and in the historical development of communication and media can likely be explained largely by the fascination exerted by the new digital media and goes hand in hand with a growing awareness of the interdependence of culture and technology.

With regard to works on media history, there are both comprehensive historical accounts and specific subfields that are subjected to thorough analysis. For example, there are anthologies in which the development of individual media—from writing to photography to the computer—is examined from both technical and sociocultural perspectives, as well as monographs of varying scope on the development of individual media or the media in general within a sociocultural context.
Some of the works on media theory are overviews that discuss individual approaches—from Benjamin to Baudrillard—while others are new editions of “classics” of media theory, such as those by Marshall McLuhan or Harold Innis, or attempts to develop an original approach, with digitization typically at the center of interest. In my view, however, no recent media-theoretical concept has yet been presented that would be capable of adequately explaining this latest development in communication technology within a broader cultural-historical context. Without going into detail here, I would nevertheless venture the thesis that many—especially postmodern—theoretical approaches mask obvious analytical shortcomings with poetic formulations whose empirical basis remains unclear.
***
This thesis attempts to meet the demands of a contemporary “sociology of art”—one that transcends disciplinary boundaries. At the same time, it proved necessary to develop a media-theoretical concept that is, on the one hand, conceptually precise and, on the other, general enough to be equally applicable to various phases of development in communication technology. Drawing primarily on concepts from the sociology of art and media—with “classical” concepts proving more useful than many newer ones—the first part of this thesis develops a theoretical approach in which communication technologies are understood as productive forces. Technological development is identified as a key determining factor that influences cultural production on an equal footing with social, economic, and political factors. This concept, which represents a theory of the media as productive forces in relation to art and cultural production, has, in my view, novelty value and—almost more importantly—explanatory value. It proves fruitful, for example, in gaining a better understanding of phenomena such as progress in the arts, the significance of copyright, the establishment of intermediary institutions (from publishing to the global cultural industry), the changing status of cultural creators, and indeed the social function of art in general.
Basierend auf dieser Produktivkrafttheorie der Medien wird im zweiten Teil der Arbeit die historische Entwicklung des Kulturschaffens unter dem Einfluss jeweils historisch neuer Kommunikationstechnologien nachgezeichnet, wobei versucht wird, den Konnex zwischen Theorie und Empirie immer wieder herzustellen. Es werden mehrere voneinander unterscheidbare Entwicklungsstufen identifiziert, die als Ergebnisse von Mediamorphosen, d.h. von umfassenden und unumkehrbaren Veränderungen des Kulturschaffens unter dem Einfluss jeweils historisch neuer Kommunikationstechnologien zu verstehen sind:
  • the first graphic mediamorphosis (with the invention of writing)
  • the second graphic mediamorphosis (with the invention of the printing press
  • the first technical, the chemical-mechanical media transformation (with the invention of photography and the phonograph
  • the second technical, the electronic media transformation (with the invention of electronic signal recording and transmission) an
  • the third technical, the digital media transformation (with the invention of the computer)
Regarding the digital mediamorphosis, it should be noted that it was only in the course of this work that the conviction took hold that this is a distinct form of mediamorphosis and not merely a further development of the electronic mediamorphosis—primarily because the digital code functions entirely differently from any analog electronic code. It is impossible to predict what developments the digital mediamorphosis—which is still in its infancy—will bring; however, the changes already evident are profound: the job profiles and professional fields of cultural practitioners are affected, as are the distribution of cultural goods, the income opportunities of cultural practitioners, copyright law, the production conditions of cultural practitioners, and those of the cultural industries, and so on and so forth. In my specific discussions of the digital metamorphosis, however, I have tried to exercise caution and restraint in light of the rapid pace of development in this area—not least because my primary concern was not to address the very latest developments or to present theories that might be spectacular but highly speculative, but rather to develop a useful and as general as possible theory for understanding the relationship between communication technologies and cultural production. With regard to digital mediamorphosis, I therefore see the primary purpose of this work as encouraging the application of the “theory of the productive forces of the media.”

Finally, an “ideological” remark: To those who find the approach of a “theory of productive forces” too materialistic, not “postmodern” enough, or perhaps even “Marxist”—the latter being a criterion that, for many, has been a reason for discrediting it since 1989—I would counter that my aim is not to advocate for an ideological position, but rather to develop a tool for capturing reality as adequately as possible, for highlighting facts that can be verified intersubjectively. I am happy to have my reflections measured against this criterion.

(from the preface)